Skip to main content
Logo icon

Main navigation

  • Home
  • News
  • Meet your MP
  • Government Support - Cost of Living
  • In Parliament
  • Campaign Responses
  • Contact
Logo icon

Domestic Homicide

  • Tweet

Thank you for contacting me about sentencing for murder. 

You are correct to say that the most serious offenders should spend more time in prison to match the severity of their crimes. The Prime Minister has been clear that the Government he leads will strengthen public confidence in the criminal justice system and I will support legislation designed to achieve this.

Murder is of course the most serious offence a person can commit. The law requires that a mandatory life sentence is imposed on anyone convicted of this crime. A life sentence remains in force for the rest of the offender’s life and release from prison, once the minimum term set by the sentencing judge has been served, is only possible if the Parole Board is satisfied that detention is no longer necessary for the protection of the public. It is important to consider that an offender serving a life sentence may never be released if the Parole Board considers they remain a danger to the public. It is also the case that if the Board does direct release it will be on life licence and subject to conditions. Therefore, the offender can be recalled to prison at any point if their risk to the public escalates. I believe this is important to consider in conjunction with the minimum period that must be served in prison before consideration of release. 

The murder of Poppy Devey Waterhouse was horrific and extremely distressing. I am aware of concerns expressed that Poppy’s murderer may have received a significantly longer minimum term in prison if it had been judged that he had brought the murder weapon to the scene of the crime.

As you have mentioned, Schedule 21 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003, states that the sentencing starting point, in a case where the offender has taken a knife or other weapon to the scene of the crime with appropriate intent and has then used that knife or weapon in committing the murder is 25 years. Poppy Devey Waterhouse’s case was not covered by this part of the legislation as the knife was not taken to the scene but was, instead, already at the scene.

It is important to consider that the statutory aggravating factors in Schedule 21, such as the degree of planning and pre-meditation that want into a murder, must be taken into account when setting the appropriate tariff. Importantly, these will apply no-matter where the murder was committed. However, the Government has been clear that all sentencing legislation and guidance is kept under review to ensure they remain fit for purpose and are fair.  

As you will be aware, the Government has proposed changes in the area of youth sentencing through the Sentencing White Paper. The purpose of the changes is to reduce the gap between the sentencing of older children and young adults. I welcome the plan to replace the current starting point of 12 years for murder committed by a child with a starting point of two-thirds the equivalent adult starting point for children aged 15-17 and half the equivalent adult starting point for children aged 10-14. After looking into this for you, these changes will mean that 15-17-year olds who commit particularly serious offences, such as murders involving sexual or sadistic conduct, will face a minimum term starting point of 20 years.

The murder of Ellie Gould was another horrific crime. I understand that the Ministry of Justice have spoken with the family as options are explored and new sentencing legislation is developed.

I welcome the Government Sentencing White Paper and am committed to scrutinising the final legislation when it is published.

Thank you again for contacting me.

Craig Whittaker MP

January 2021

Campaign Responses

  • Archived Campaign Responses
  • Covid-19: Extending Support Schemes
  • Covid-19: Provision of Tests
  • Covid-19: Vaccinating Children
  • Covid-19: Vaccines and Developing Countries
  • Abortion At Home
  • Abortion Time Limit: Foetal Viability
  • Aid Spending
  • Animal Research
  • Animal Sentience: Update January 2022
  • Animal Welfare
  • Assisted Suicide
  • Asylum Seekers: Employment
  • Badgers and Bovine TB
  • Beer and Alcohol Duty (incudes Draught Beer)
  • Business, Human Rights and Environment: June 2022
  • Caged Farm Animals
  • Cambo & Oil Fields
  • CatchUpWithCancer
  • Cats & Kittens
  • Channel 4 Privatisation
  • Clean Air
  • Clean Heat: Heat Pumps
  • Clean Heat: Energy Efficiency
  • Climate and Ecological Emergency Bill
  • Climate Issues (plus COP 26)
  • Commercial Sexual Exploitation
  • Conversion Therapy
  • COP26: Global Action
  • Cost of Living
  • Council Workers' and Public Sector Pay
  • Cut Carbon Not Forests: Update
  • Cycling and Walking: Update
  • Dangerous Dogs Act
  • Debt and DROs
  • Decarbonisation and Economic Strategy Bill
  • Dementia Diagnosis
  • Dentistry
  • Deporting Foreign Criminals: June 2022
  • Disability Benefits Assessments: EDM 19
  • Domestic Abuse Bill
  • Domestic Abuse: Migrants
  • Domestic Homicide
  • Domestic Abuse: Universal Credit
  • Early Years Funding
  • Elections Act and the Electoral Commission
  • End Child Food Poverty
  • Endometriosis and PCOS
  • Energy Costs and the Windfall Tax
  • Environmental Land Management
  • E-scooters (Guide Dogs)
  • Equal Pay
  • EU/EEA Settled Status
  • Face Coverings
  • Fire & Rehire
  • Fix Bad Housing
  • Flexible Working
  • Foie Gras and Fur
  • Food Waste
  • Fuel Duty and Prices
  • Gamebird Battery Cages
  • Gambling Review
  • Gender Recognition Act: June 2022
  • Global Malnutrition
  • Global Partnership for Education
  • GP Issues
  • Guards’ Bearskins: Updated June 2022
  • Hamas
  • Health & Care Bill (including Workforce)
  • Heart and Circulatory Diseases
  • Hedgehogs
  • Hedgerows
  • Holiday Tax Lets
  • HS2
  • Human Rights Act
  • Human Rights Defenders
  • Humanist Marriages
  • Hunting Act
  • Immigration and Refugees
  • Israel is not an Apartheid State
  • Israel: Stop BDS
  • Israel: UK Arms and Right to Self-defence
  • Ivory Act: Update
  • Jagtar Singh Johal
  • Legal Aid: Asylum and Immigration Cases
  • Levelling-up: Transport
  • Live Animal Exports
  • Local Electricity Bill
  • Medical Cannabis
  • Mental Health Research
  • Migrant Channel Crossings
  • Misogyny
  • MP's & Second Jobs
  • Multi-sensory Impairment: Education
  • National Insurance Increase (NHS & Social Care)
  • Nationality and Borders Bill: Asylum-seekers
  • NHS Funding
  • NHS Pay: Consultants, Doctors and Dentists
  • NHS Pay and Recruitment
  • Night Time Industries
  • Northern Ireland Protocol
  • Nuclear Weapons
  • Ocean Protection
  • Off-payroll Working (IR35)
  • Older People: Health and Care
  • Palestinian Human Rights Defenders
  • 'Partygate': Fixed Penalty Notices
  • Peat
  • Pension Credit
  • Pensioner Poverty
  • Persecution of Christians: Updated May 2022
  • Planning Bill
  • Plastic Waste
  • Police Corruption & Accountability
  • Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Bill: February 2022
  • Pregnancy and Maternity Redundancy Bill
  • Proportional Property Tax
  • Public Sector Pay (Civil Service)
  • Public Sexual Harassment: Crime not Compliment (Jan 22)
  • Rail Strikes
  • Rape and the Criminal Justice System
  • Reception Baseline Assessment (Primary Schools)
  • Renters Reform Bill: Updated
  • Retail Workers: Protection at Work
  • Royal Corruption
  • Rwanda Partnership: Tackling Illegal Immigration and People Smugglers
  • School Breakfast Bill
  • Sentencing (Dangerous Driving)
  • Sewage Discharges
  • Small Brewers Relief
  • Snares
  • Social Care Charging Reforms
  • Social Housing
  • Speed Limits
  • Stamp Duty Land Tax
  • Syria
  • Teachers' Pay
  • Trade Deals: Farming and Food Standards
  • Trade Deals: Food Standards
  • Trade Deals: NHS - New Clause 17 and Lords 11
  • Trade Deals: Parliamentary Scrutiny
  • Trains and Planes
  • Triple Lock (State Pension)
  • Trophy Hunting Update
  • Trespass (Right to Roam)
  • Ukraine
  • Ukraine: Refugees
  • UN Treaty on Business and Human Rights
  • Unaccompanied Child Refugees
  • Universal Credit
  • Vagrancy Act and the PCSC Bill (Lords Amendment)
  • Vaping and E-Cigarettes
  • VAT on Electric Vehicle Charging in Public Places
  • Violence against Women and Girls
  • Visa-free Work Permits for Touring Artists
  • Voting Systems
  • Water, Sanitation and Hygiene (UK Aid)
  • Wayne Couzens Inquiry
  • Young People's Mental Health
  • Youth Homelessness: Chance to Move On

Craig Whittaker MP for Calder Valley

Footer

  • About RSS
  • Accessibility
  • Cookies
  • Privacy
  • About Craig
  • Campaign Responses
  • In Parliament
This website is funded by the Independent Parliamentary Standards Authority (IPSA) for the purpose of assisting Craig Whittaker MP in the performance of their Parliamentary duties.
Copyright 2022 Craig Whittaker MP for Calder Valley. All rights reserved.
Powered by Bluetree